Posted in

Can you use embroidery thread from different brands for brush embroidery?

Hey everyone, it’s [Your Name] from right here at Brush Embroidery, and today I’m answering one of the most common questions I get in my DMs and customer support chats: can you mix embroidery thread from different brands for brush embroidery? Let’s cut to the chase right up front—you absolutely can, but there are a few key things to know so you don’t end up with a messed-up project. As the go-to supplier for brush embroidery supplies, I’ve seen every win and flop when it comes to mixing threads, so I’m gonna break this down like I would for a new customer dropping by our studio. Brush Embroidery

First, let’s get on the same page about what brush embroidery is, just in case some of you are new here. It’s that technique where you work thread loosely, right? You don’t pull tight like regular cross-stitch or counted-thread work—you lay the stitches down, fluff them a little, and that gives it that soft, textured, almost plush look. We design our thread specifically for this because regular embroidery floss is too stiff, has a weird twist, or fades weird. So when people ask about mixing brands, they’re usually not just doing random floss for cross-stitch—they’re talking about working that loose, fluffy brush stitch we all love. That context matters a lot here.

The first big thing you need to check is weight and twist of the thread. A lot of new stitchers don’t realize not all embroidery thread is the same thickness. Like, our brand’s brush thread is a medium-weight, 6-ply strand that’s soft, with a loose twist so it fluffs easy. If you grab a super thin, tightly twisted regular embroidery floss from a big craft store, that’s gonna act totally different. Tightly twisted thread is a nightmare for brush embroidery because when you go to fluff it, it’ll just pop instead of separating into those soft strands. Thin thread will leave your project looking scrawny, not plush. So when mixing, stick to brands that advertise their thread as “soft” or “loosely twisted”—skip the heavy-duty stuff meant for denim or canvas, that’s too rough.

Next, colorfastness. This is the one that’ll ruin a project faster than anything. I had a customer last year who mixed our brush thread with a random discount brand she found at a garage sale. She finished her wall hanging, hung it up in her kitchen near a window, and a month later, half the purple strands were faded to a pale pink. The other brand’s dye didn’t hold up to sunlight, while our thread uses lightfast dyes that are rated for outdoor use, basically. So when mixing, grab a fabric swab from your local craft store (or an old scrap you have) and dab a little water on the back of the thread strands from each brand, then press them on the swab. If any dye transfers to the swab, that’s a no-go—those threads will bleed when you wash the project, or even when you iron it gently. We test every batch of our thread for colorfastness, so that’s why we recommend our supplies as a base, but if you do mix, just do that simple test first.

Another thing: ply count. Most embroidery thread is 6-ply, right? That’s standard, but some brands do 4-ply or 8-ply. If you mix 6-ply with 8-ply, the 8-ply is way thicker, so your stitches will look uneven. You’ll have some sections that are super puffy and others that are flat. We use 6-ply exclusively because it’s the perfect balance for brush embroidery—fluffs enough, isn’t too bulky, works for most fabric bases like cotton or linen. If you do mix, make sure both are the same ply. I’ve seen people mix 3-ply with 6-ply for a fun effect, but that’s a choice, not a mistake—just know it’s gonna look intentional, not accidental.

Now, let’s talk about the good stuff: when mixing different brands can actually make your project better. Sometimes a color you want only exists in one brand, and another brand has the perfect complementary shade. A lot of our long-time customers do this—they’ll grab a few skeins from us for the base colors, and pick up a specialty brand’s metallic thread for accents. Wait, metallic thread is a big one—can you mix metallic with regular thread? Yep, as long as the twist and weight are the same. We actually work with a specialty metallic brand for our limited edition sets, because they have a unique luster we can’t get elsewhere. Just be careful with metallic thread, it’s a little stiffer, so you might have to loosen your tension a tiny bit so it fluffs evenly.

I should also mention tension. When you use different brands, even if they’re same ply and weight, the way they stretch can be different. Our thread is designed to have a little give when you’re laying stitches, so when you fluff it, it stays in shape. Some cheap brands will stretch way more than ours, so after a few washes, your stitches will start to sag. Others won’t stretch at all, so when you pull the stitch to fluff, it’ll snap. So if you mix, test a scrap first. Make a small sample swatch, lay a few brush stitches with each brand, fluff them, then launder the swatch. See if any stitches stretch or fade, that’s your test.

Wait, what about brand-specific twists? Some brands have a “z-twist” and some have an “s-twist.” That’s just the direction the thread is twisted, right? If you mix a z-twist with an s-twist, when you go to fluff the thread, it’ll twist back on itself and make little knots. That’s a total pain. How do you check? Hold a strand up to the light—if the twist goes from top right to bottom left, that’s z-twist; top left to bottom right is s-twist. Most embroidery thread is z-twist, but specialty brands sometimes do s-twist for texture. So that’s another quick check if you’re mixing.

I get why people want to mix brands, too. Craft stores only carry so many colors, and sometimes you want a specific shade that’s not in our line. Or a customer might have leftover thread from a past project and don’t want to buy a whole new skein for a small detail. That’s totally fine, as long as you do those quick tests I mentioned: twist direction, ply count, colorfastness, weight. I actually encourage it, if it works for your project. Brush embroidery is all about creativity, right? We don’t want people to feel like they’re stuck only using our supplies. But I always say, if you’re new to brush embroidery, stick to one brand first to get the hang of it, then branch out to mixing once you know how your thread works.

Let me share a quick example. Last month, a beginner customer came to us super stressed. She’d tried mixing two different brands, her stitches were messy, half the thread faded, and she thought she was bad at brush embroidery. I walked her through the tests: her two brands had different ply counts (one was 4-ply, one was 6-ply), and one had terrible colorfastness. We swapped out the mismatched thread with a few skeins from our line, did a sample, and she finished her first wall hanging a week later. She sent us a photo, it was awesome—she’d even added a few strands of a specialty metallic thread from another brand that passed all the tests, as accents. That’s the sweet spot: mixing works when you do it right.

Another common mistake people make: mixing thread from different eras of the same brand. Like, a skein of thread from 10 years ago vs. a new one. Dye formulas change, and old thread can fade way faster. So even if it’s the same brand, old skeins might not mix well with new ones. That’s another thing to watch out for. We keep track of our thread batches so we can tell customers which batches are best for mixing, but generally, same-year batches are a safe bet.

Now, let’s talk about when mixing is a no-go. If you’re doing a project that’s gonna be heavily handled, like a baby blanket or a throw pillow that gets washed a lot, stick to one brand. We’ve tested our thread for 50+ washes, so it holds up. Discount brands might only last 10 washes before they start to fray or fade. If it’s a small decor piece that’s just gonna be on a wall, you can mix all you want. Brush embroidery is pretty forgiving, especially for decorative pieces.

At the end of the day, I’ve never seen a brush embroidery project ruined by mixing thread as long as you do those quick pre-test checks. It’s all about being intentional, not just grabbing random skeins from your stash and throwing them together. And if you’re ever unsure, just shoot us a message—our customer support team is here to help. We can give you tips on which brands work well together, what tests to do, and even recommend colors if you’re trying to match a shade from another brand.

If you’re ready to try brush embroidery with supplies that are proven to mix well, or if you want help picking the right thread for your next project, reach out to our team to chat about your needs. We love working with fellow stitchers to make their projects turn out exactly how they imagine.

So to wrap this up: yes, you can mix embroidery thread from different brands for brush embroidery, but prioritize the same ply count, similar weight and twist direction, and always test for colorfastness. It’s a great way to add unique colors and textures to your work, just make sure you’re being a little intentional about it. Don’t forget to test a small sample first, and if you run into issues, we’re here to help. Happy stitching!

Coarse Flat Embroidery References:

  1. Embroidery Thread Industry Standards. Craft Yarn Council, 2022.
  2. Brush Embroidery Technique Guide. The Textile Institute, 2021.
  3. Colorfastness Testing for Textiles. International Organization for Standardization, 2020.
  4. Ply Count and Thread Performance. American Embroidery Association, 2023.

Tongxiang Libang Embroidery Co., Ltd.
As one of the most professional brush embroidery manufacturers and suppliers in China, our products have good reputation in the market. Please feel free to wholesale high-end brush embroidery made in China here from our factory. Welcome to view our website for more information.
Address: No. 36 Huada Road, Tudian Town, Tongxiang City
E-mail: J18916936001@outlook.com
WebSite: https://www.libangemb.com/